What a Buy-Side Investor Needs to See Before Committing Capital

Five questions from a real evaluation, with lessons for any IR team

Rethink Your Earnings Presentation Before January Hits

If you are planning your IR priorities for next year, there is a window right now to get a head start before earnings season kicks off in January. We have been running what we call an Earnings Diagnostic for IR teams that want to rethink how their earnings presentations work. 

It is a focused two-to-three-week engagement ($10,000 to $15,000) where we review your current earnings materials, identify gaps in your messaging and design, and deliver a roadmap: where your narrative should go, how the deck should be structured, and what a repeatable earnings system would look like for your company. You walk away with a clear direction and a blueprint for the full build, not the build itself. 

A few of our current clients started exactly this way. It is also a practical use of remaining 2026 budget, since the work carries directly into next year.

If you want to explore it, book a session below.

A buy-side investor with a concentrated fund recently walked through how he evaluates a company before giving it a 15% position. The company is Toast, the restaurant technology platform. But the framework applies to any business trying to earn and keep investor conviction.

Sean Barrett, founder and CIO of Counter Global, first invested in Toast in 2020. In a recent Business Breakdowns episode, he laid out what convinced him to build that position and what keeps him there. What stood out is how closely his evaluation connects to five of the six factors we typically work through when shaping an investor story.

These are the same questions every serious investor is asking about your company right now, whether you hear about it or not.

1. Is Your Company on the Right Side of the Trend That Matters Most?

Every industry has a defining trend, and investors want to know whether your company benefits from it or gets disrupted by it. Right now in software, that trend is AI, and it has investors questioning which businesses will hold their ground.

Sean calls AI probably “the best thing to happen to Toast” since its founding. About half the US restaurant market still runs on legacy on-premise systems, where an update can mean sending a technician to each location. Toast runs in the cloud, so new AI features reach its entire customer base at once. The faster AI improves, the wider that gap gets.

It is already showing up in the product. Restaurant owners can use ToastIQ, their conversational AI tool, to ask questions about sales data and make menu changes across locations. Sean says roughly half of Toast’s customers use it every week.

For your own story: Can you articulate, with evidence, how the biggest trend reshaping your industry makes your business stronger? If the answer requires more than a sentence of explanation, your investors are likely building their own narrative for you.

2. If a Well-Funded Competitor Showed Up Tomorrow, Would Your Customers Stay?

Every investor wants to know what protects your business when a competitor arrives with more money or a cheaper product. Sean points to the parts of Toast that are not code: purpose-built hardware, the supply chain behind it, and sales teams on the ground in every major US city. These are expensive, physical things that a new entrant cannot replicate quickly.

But the most compelling evidence came from the field. DoorDash is piloting its own point-of-sale system, so Sean’s team visited 30 to 40 San Francisco restaurants that use both platforms. Not one said they would switch, even if DoorDash’s system were free. The economics explain why: Toast restaurants earn about a 15% margin compared with roughly 10% for a typical restaurant, and Toast costs them around $10,000 a year against average customer revenue of $1.3 million. Toast’s customers are more profitable, which means they also survive longer, driving the kind of retention numbers that are hard for competitors to disrupt.

For your own story: If a competitor offered your product for free, would your customers stay? If you cannot answer that with field evidence, your investors probably cannot either.

3. Has Your Management Team Earned the Right to Make Bold Claims?

Sean evaluates management on three pillars: integrity, ambition, and innovation. Ambition is where Toast stands out. In 2020, Toast had 20,000 to 30,000 restaurant locations and was already talking about reaching 200,000, then 400,000. Everyone thought they were crazy.

Toast now has more than 160,000 locations and Sean expects it to reach 200,000 by the end of this year or early 2027. That track record gives its next ambition a hearing: growing gross profit from about $2 billion to $10 billion. The three co-founders, who met while studying computer science at MIT, still lead the company. Sean calls them “the team you want in an AI world.”

For your own story: Every management team makes forward-looking claims. The question is whether you have delivered enough past results to make those claims credible. Bold targets without a visible track record behind them are promises investors have no reason to believe.

4. Can You Explain What Repeats in Your Revenue, and Why?

About two-thirds of Toast’s roughly $2 billion in gross profit comes from payments, with the rest from software. So the podcast host asked a fair question: Is that really recurring revenue?

Sean did not overclaim. Payments are not contractual the way software subscriptions are, and they can move with transaction volumes. But they are tied to restaurant activity, which tends to grow with inflation and GDP. As Sean puts it, “if the customers turn off Toast, they can’t run their business.” The rest of the financial picture supports the quality: EBITDA margins have moved from about minus 16% in 2022 to roughly 35%, gross profit continues to grow at more than 25%, and R&D spending barely grew over two years even as the business doubled. Sean calls Toast “a very easy business to model.”

For your own story: Investors do not need every dollar to be contractually recurring. They need to understand what repeats, what drives it, and how reliably it grows. If your recurring revenue story requires a footnote to explain, that explanation might be the story you should be telling more clearly.

5. Where Is the Next Phase of Growth, and Are You Already There?

In 2020, Toast focused on small US restaurants. Today, it is selling to larger chains like Applebee’s, grocery stores, gas stations, and hotels including Marriott, while expanding internationally into the UK, Ireland, Canada, and Australia. Sean says those international markets are growing faster than Toast grew in the US when it started.

The core US market still has room to run. Sean describes a local-market flywheel: Toast might start with 2% share in a city, and once it reaches about 10%, adoption accelerates as restaurants see their peers on the platform. Some cities are already at 25% to 30% share, and those cities are actually adding share faster than newer markets.

New products add another layer. Toast Grow, an automated marketing tool at about $500 a month, has shown early users an 8% revenue lift, roughly 20 times the cost of the product.

For your own story: If your growth narrative depends entirely on a market you have not entered yet, investors will discount it. The most convincing expansion stories show early traction in the new market alongside continued opportunity in the existing one.

The Evaluation Is Already Happening

These five questions are not theoretical. They are the actual framework a concentrated fund manager used to build and hold one of his largest positions. And they are the same questions being asked about your company right now.

The difference between companies that earn long-term investor conviction and those that do not often comes down to something simple: the companies that earn it give investors evidence they can test, not just claims they have to accept. Sean’s evaluation of Toast is worth studying not because Toast is unique, but because it is a clear example of what earning conviction looks like. The question for your IR team is whether your own investor story holds up under the same scrutiny.

Listen to the full Business Breakdowns episode on Toast.

Check Out Some of Our Recent IR Presentation Projects

Learn more about OUTKREATE’s Investor Relations Solutions

We help Investor Relations teams to ELEVATE presentations for any occasion – be it your novelty Investor Day, General Overview, Quarterly Earnings, Investor Conferences, ESG Updates.

Thinking of UPGRADING your Investor Materials?
TALK THROUGH YOUR PRESENTATION CHALLENGE

How does your Presentation measure up?

Do you have a major event or a high-stakes meeting coming up? Do you need a sharp narrative and bold design?

Let's connect and we can take a closer look at your presentations. We'll share with you actionable ideas along with real examples that you can apply to improve odds of success.

Book an introductory call